Disclaimers: The characters in this story belong to Fox, 1013 and Chris Carter. No money is being made from the use of these characters and no infringement is intended. Any other references to any other work of poetry or cinema belong to who ever they belong to, but not to me. Summary: Reunited, Mulder and Samantha pursue the truth, hoping to find a cure for Scully along the way, but find there are dangerous consequences to the pursuit of truth. Follow up story to "Diary". Thanks to Renee, Jenn and Sally for their enthusiasm and to Bob (LOML) for all the encouragement, time off, patience, input, and editing. A special nod to Nick for a great idea. Rating is PG-13. Spoilers range from the 1st through the 4th Season including Demons. Category: XA lizmcrae@aol.com For the purposes of this story, assume that Gethsamane has not happened. This is a follow up to "The Diary" which I strongly suggest you read first so you have a point of reference for this story. This is the second story in a series titled Duplicity. Duplicity: I am I by Liz McRae 5/17/97 Maryland State Penitentiary, Women's Facility April, 1986 "The soul takes flight to the world that is invisible, and upon arriving, is assured of bliss." Where had she heard that before? Read it in a book, heard it in a movie, from a priest? It didn't matter now. It would all be over soon, and like the small black birds racing across the gray sky outside her window, she would know bliss. And if not bliss, then at least no more regret. She turns her head to feel the cool of the smooth- painted cinder block against her bruised cheek. Once more she is aware of the smell of too many women confined to too small a space, the sounds of their frustration, anger, pleasure and sadness swirling around the cellblocks up through the atrium like some communal heart beat. Two guards arrive at the gate to her cell. "Visitor," the taller one informs her. "Who?" she asks, making no move to rise from her seat on the cement floor beside the narrow bed. She knows no one. "Get up." She struggles, feeling dizzy. A hand circles around her upper arm, pulling her up. She stands and sways. The other guard takes hold of her other arm. The floor seems to shift planes and alternately feels solid or soft like a sponge. They lead her into one of the tiny visitor rooms usually reserved for prisoners and attorneys. It is furnished with a white enameled metal table and two old-fashioned metal office chairs. An older man stands by the door leading to the administrative end of the prison. The guards seat her at the table. She spreads her hands across the table top, wanting to put her face down too. Only after the guards leave does the older man approach the table. He regards her for some time. She doesn't flinch under his scrutiny until his eyes lock with hers and hold them. Then she looks away, down at the table, shame spreading across her face, tears welling in her eyes. "You're not my father, are you?" she whispers, every muscle taught with fear. "No," he says and she relaxes enough to chew her numb lip before asking, "Who then?" "A friend." "I don't have any friends." "What do you think you're doing?" he asks pulling out the chair and sliding into it. She shakes her head, unsure how to answer, not even understanding the question. "Don't you see, you've been given a chance here," he continues, "This is your opportunity to put the past behind you. This is the first step on the road to finding your truth." "I don't...who are you? Why?" She is even more confused. "You must not continue your present course. There are people out there hoping you will fail, maybe even plotting to ensure your failure. But you can use this time wisely. Gather your strength, make use of the tools here. Don't give up." "I don't understand," the tears that had welled for a moment and then stilled, now slip over her lower lashes and stream down her cheeks. Her fingers clench in anger. Who is this man to make her come unglued like this? "You want to know, don't you? The truth?" he asks and she hates him. "Don't let them beat you. Fight them. Fight them by educating yourself, making yourself healthy." "Why do you care?" she spits at him. "Because, Miss Fox. I care about the truth." **************************** Present Day He has three photos of me in his living room. One of me standing on a jungle gym sits on his desk. Two more, of both of us, on the bookshelf. They mock me with smiling faces of times I can't remember and places I can't name. But there are no pictures of them. It is strange to me, how I feel about my father's death. My brother told me carefully, gently. I stared at him incredulous. Why would he think it would upset me? I hated our father. I hated what he did to Fox. Later, that night lying in my bed, I cried. Actually, I sobbed. I regret the timing of his death, because I'll never have the chance to tell him how I've hated him. But honestly, more than that, I regret that I'll never feel that power one more time. The rush I got from his love for me, because he loved me more than Fox. Never laid a dangerous hand on me. Never raised his voice in anger or contempt to me. And I could still his violence against Fox, with just the touch of my hand. I shake my head, banishing those sick, sick feelings. Of course my brother wouldn't have a framed snap shot of the man that tortured him. And just the same, I'd have liked to have seen how he looked later in life. "Here," he says, returning from the kitchen, extending an iced tea bottle to me. I watch as he thumbs through his CDs. I had thought I looked much older than he when we first met again, but now I can see the lines in his forehead, the crows feet, and wariness in his eyes. Perhaps we look about the same age. "How was school today?" he asks. I nod my head, "My Oral is Wednesday," I tell him. "And then?" he sits beside me, dragging a wedge of pita bread through the humus. "Then I get my Masters and I'm qualified to rule the world, or assist current world rulers," I try to be funny and he plops the heavy pita-humus combination in his mouth. "Do you have any plans?" I feel like I'm being grilled so I get up and move around the room. "I've applied for a translator-assistant position at the UN," I know it doesn't sound like much, and he seems underwhelmed, so I add, "Despite my high marks and the degree, I'm still a convicted felon. It does limit career opportunities." I go to the window. I'm embarrassed. He's embarrassed. I should have taken the train back to Baltimore this evening. He comes up behind me and puts his hand on my shoulder, "Sam..." his voice is sad but soothing, "No one is judging. You don't have to worry about any expectations." I whip around, feeling my cheeks flush. "Yes I do. There are plenty of expectations. Not just hers, not just yours, but mine too. I have expectations; had expectations," I correct myself. "I spent years dreaming of some sort or reunion. Now it's happened. And you are the only pleasant surprise. The only part that turned out better than I imagined. Better than I could have hoped for. You don't know how many kids I met..." I don't want to get into that, so I let it go. Besides, he's a forensic psychologist, he knows. "Dad is dead. I'll never get to confront him, never get to say good-bye. And her..." I feel the rage moving up my spine, making me shake, remembering our reunion of only a few days ago, "I spent a long time talking to professionals about Mother. I thought I'd be able to take seeing her again as a matter of course, with little emotional investment. And in just a few minutes, she, she..." the hot tears well and begin to roll, I press my head against the window, "she broke your heart and made me feel so dirty." I push away from the window, away from Fox, and pace his living room. There isn't enough air. "I've spent half a lifetime looking for the person I was. Well now I've found Sam, but I can't just pretend that Kathy never existed, as happy as that would make everyone. I'm not proud of the road I took Fox, but I survived the journey and I think that's something to be proud of." He moves quickly toward me. For an instant I'm afraid, because I know he is going to hold me. He does, in strong arms, his hand strokes my hair, he whispers reassurances in my ear and I realize it has been three years since anyone has done that. I bury my face in his shoulder and pretend. "I'm stronger than this. I'm sorry," I tell him, afraid he will find me lacking. "Don't be ridiculous. This is a roller coaster for all of us, particularly for you because of the memory issues. I think you may be among the strongest people I've ever met. I don't think I would have survived what you did Sam." My eyes well up again, but not because he's saying something nice to me. It's because he wants me to believe his life has been easier than mine and I see little evidence of that. As we pull away, a few minutes and a few tears later, he points toward the desk, "Kleenex." I pull at the tissue, but it doesn't come right out. The box sort of skips over the desk top and knocks a file folder. A handful of pictures slide out, your face right on top. Something closes tight around my chest. Three years. I thought I remembered your face perfectly, but I see I've lost some of the details. I turn around, holding your picture, my mouth forming the word Ôwhy'. Fox is immediately anxious, he sets the food back down on the coffee table. "You know that man?" he asks. "Yes!" I shouldn't have been surprised. There is a reason for everything with you. There is no random chance. "How?" he asks, reasonably enough, but I don't want to start. I want him to tell me first. It's safer that way. "Why do you have his photograph?" my voice cracks. "He was an informant, sort of. He provided me with information, so long as it was in his best interest. That's what he used to say," he shrugs as he says it. "He saved my life, at the cost of his own." I can see he's afraid to say more about you, until he knows about me. "How do you know him?" he asks then. My eyes travel around the room quickly. How do I know you? How can I sum up what you were to me, what you still are? "He saved my life too," I say it warmly, feeling the wonder of it again. I tell him how you came to me in prison. You made me feel valuable; worth something for the first time in so very many years. Because of you, I explain, I completed two sessions of rehab, spent years with the counselors, took the high school equivalency. I tell him about the curriculum you made me study for college; how you tested me, grilled me, pushed me, yelled at me, taught me. Four years out of prison, and I'll be getting an MA in International Relations from Johns Hopkins. I'm fluent in two languages, proficient in a third, and Chinese...well, Chinese is just really hard for me. My brother smiles in a way that says ÔIsn't that nice', but I sense he has become uneasy again. I have failed to make him understand how important you were to me. "If he knew about you, why wouldn't he tell me. Or why didn't he tell you about me?" "It is possible that he didn't know it was me," he shakes his head, violently no. "Ok, I agree that seems unlikely. But Fox, he never did anything without thinking it through first, and without a damn good reason," he scoffs at me in a typical older brother way. ÔWhat could you know?' I let him, because there is no way I can tell him why you didn't bring us together before you died. I ask him how you died - I have already guessed why you died. You gave Scully the same advice you were always giving me. Trust no one. I don't, except my brother, and only so far. You taught me well. We continue to talk and it becomes apparent that the biggest obstacle before us is my memory, or lack of it. "I'll call Werber," he says. "The hypnosis guy?" I'm uneasy and it shows. "Sam, it's ok. Really. Do you want to hear my tape?" Yes. Yes I do want to hear his tape. And maybe he'll forget about the whole thing if I listen to his tape and remember something. "You're frightened," he says, because I shiver. You know me, temperature regulation is not one of my strengths and then I realize I am shivering because I am frightened. Whatever happened that night, he blocked from his memory and I blocked from mine. I'm not sure I want to know, but I know that I will submit to his Dr. Werber because this man has spent his whole life preparing to solve this mystery. It seems the least I can do. "It's ok, I'll be right there with you. You won't be alone, Sam." My brother is either very important or very pushy because he gets Werber to agree to see us tomorrow morning. Since it's midnight, I guess he must be both pushy and important. He starts to close the door of his bedroom after getting me something to sleep in and a fresh towel, "What did you call him?" I ask. "Deep Throat," he replies, "You?" "Friend." Maybe he does understand, just a little, I decide as his eyes smile back at me. "Sweet dreams Sam." **************************** I sit in the flickering silence of the TV feeling all- over tired but afraid to sleep. There was a time I might have grudgingly acknowledged I was overly paranoid. Not any more, not after tonight. What a brilliant mindfuck he was. He knew where Samantha was all along. How many others knew? I can't help but wonder if the great secret of the universe isn't fucking the Mulders. She's just as blind to him as I used to be. Scully is the only one that saw him clearly. I look at her face when she talks about him, how wonderful she thinks he was, how he saved her life, and I can't miss the love she still feels for him. I recognize the debt I owe him for turning her life around, for saving her and me, but I'm so disappointed to find yet another lie. I have to wonder for the millionth time, who left Sam's diary on my doorstep, and why now. Maybe somehow, if this can ever be all over, if we can find a way to make Scully well, I'll walk away. The prospect of a remote cabin or island appeals to my exhausted self. If we can make Scully well. We must make Scully well. **************************** I walk down Werber's long stair case as he instructs. I pause at the door he describes, and when I push it open my breath catches. Jesus, here we are in the past. It's my front yard. There's a blue car, a Chrysler, in the driveway. Grandfather is about to get into it, but he stops and pushes the door closed again before he squats down in front on me. He takes my hands in his. They are thick, warm. When he speaks it is with an accent. ÔYou will take very good care of your brother, won't you? He's been so ill, forgotten so many things. But you'll help him, won't you? You'll keep him safe, yes?' I nod. He smiles and pulls a fresh pack of Fruit Stripe gum out of his pocket. ÔGood girl.' he says and kisses my forehead. I sense more than I actually hear voices whispering near me, up the staircase. I don't try to listen. Grandfather's come back. He's talking with Dad and Mom. School starts again tomorrow. Fox is going to go with a cast on his arm. Dad broke it last night. When he goes to get in his car, I run after him. I am trying to tell him that I've been trying to keep him safe, but he won't listen to me. His face is red. He looks angry, like Dad does with Fox. I back away because now I am afraid. That afternoon I sit in Fox's room. We are very quiet because Mom and Dad are yelling downstairs. About Fox. We are drawing pictures of places we'd like to live. Places we'd rather live. Fox draws the moon and I draw a castle that flies so I can visit him on the moon. My picture is better because my hand isn't in a cast. "Samantha, can you remember the night you were taken?" Werber's voice isn't far away up the stairs anymore, it's down here with me. The noise is shaking the house. The lights are so bright my eyes burn when I look at them. Fox is calling me. Someone grabs me around the middle. It's so tight, I can't wiggle out. I'm crying and I can't make a sound because he's squeezing so tight, I can't catch my breath. He's taking me outside, toward the light and the noise. I can see Fox, he's kneeling on the floor...the man holding me turns and the bright light in is my face again. He throws me into the big car. It's tall. I smell Mom. Someone else grabs me, they pull a pillow case over my face. There is a sharp stinging on my arm. I feel so heavy. "Is there any more? What about later?" I am always cold, except in my belly, between my hips. It burns there. When I try to roll over to my side, I can't. It is white everywhere. I can't really see anything. They keep pulling at me. Pulling from the inside. I have a picture in my mind of scraping out a pumpkin, just before you carve it. My teeth hurt because I clench them so tight. I'm throwing up. Throwing up makes me cry. I'm choking and I can't turn over. I hear them whispering on the stairs again and I remember waking up later, wearing a diaper. It makes me angry so I take it off. It is filled with blood and I get dizzy. Sometime later,when I don't have to wear the diapers anymore, a man comes for me. We drive a long way. He calls me Kathy and he smokes cigarettes, one after the other. ÔI meet Howard and...' "Wake her up!" It's his voice, Fox's, I hear it on the stairs, behind me. Then Dr. Werber tells me to follow him back up the stairs. I open my eyes and look at my brother. He looks like shit. I feel a little sick to my stomach. "Ladies room?" I ask and as soon as I step inside I lock the door and slide down the cool tile wall, wrapping my arms around myself. I will not lose it. I will keep it together. I need you. I want to feel your arms around me. I close my eyes tight and I see and feel you hug me the day I got equivalency certificate. Good, but I've got a better one now. A year or so later. You came to pick up the essay on how the closed European state system of the 19th century evolved into the international system by the early 20th century. I was so nervous, chewing on my lip, on the inside of my cheeks. You were completely silent, completely expressionless. Page one, page two, page three. No clues through eight pages of neat cursive on college ruled notebook paper. Then you set it down and looked at me. I was about to crumble when your face broke into such a wide, warm smile. You started to laugh and got up from your chair, holding your arms out to me. I felt your pride in me and later, when I walked back down the corridor through one gate and another, metal slamming against metal, I had a sense of future. And even though I was heading back to my cell, I took a new feeling of freedom with me. Now I take a deep breath and I can feel that same strength again. I'm ten feet tall when I stand back up in that shrink's bathroom. **************************** "I recognized that man that took me to Howard and Carol's. I met him again, years later." "I recognized him from the description in your diary." Oh God, the diary. How can I keep forgetting about that. He's read it. I can't even look at it. When he tried to give it back to me... "When I think that sick bastard named me Kathy *Fox*. Fox! I know I've said it was sick before, a sick joke, but now that I know who was behind it..." "We should go to Connecticut right now," he says, drumming his fingers on the steering wheel while we wait at a red light. "No. I'm not going to Connecticut. I'm going back to Baltimore." "We have to. You said you smelled Mom when you were taken," he insists, while accelerating quickly. "Yeah, well I also told you all about a Grandfather you say we didn't have. How do you know me smelling Mom is reliable? Besides, she's only going to work me up and I have my Oral tomorrow. "I'm not going to Connecticut. If you don't want to take me to Baltimore, pull over right here and I'll get the train." "Sam..." "You are the most annoying... You don't take no for an answer do you? I said no and I meant it. Scully must be dying to be rid of you," I don't know what it is I've said, but everything about him is changing. Where he was rigid and excited, bright and alert, he's become tired, weary, collapsed and dull. It makes me think someone let the air out of him. "What did I say?" he's massaging his temple lightly. He draws in a deep breath and lets it out very slowly. "Scully is dying." I feel like I've been hit. I don't really know her. I've only met her once, talked to her on the phone another time. But I do know that they are a team, partners. I know she's shared in his search for me, supported him, doctored and nursed him. "I don't...I'm sorry, why?" it's the best English I can speak. Strangely, I form a perfect Russian sentence in my head. "Brain tumor. Inoperable, fatal, unless... there have been other cases like hers, Sam. Women that were abducted... as she was... as you were," he says, becoming more animated again, "Things were done to them. I think similar things were done to you too," the gravity of what he is saying begins to pull me back down. I had thought he was awfully tenacious about discovering the truth behind my abduction and what went on. I understand the reason behind his tenacity now. "Let's go to Connecticut then," I say. What else can I say? But he doesn't want me to. "No, you're right. Your memory may be playing tricks on you. You have your Oral tomorrow and that's too important. Besides, Mom might react better if it's just me." That's probably the truth. "Are you sure?" "Completely." **************************** It's only after I get home and lock the door behind me that I can let my mind go. Holy Shit! I think of how many years I spent thinking Kathy Fox's life was a disaster between the drugs, prostitution, disease, murder, and prison. It seems strangely dull, stereotypical even, compared to the life of Samantha Mulder. Child abuse, abduction, reproductive mutilation, genetic tampering, white slavery... I have to remind myself again, I am Kathy. I am Sam. I am I. Fox says we didn't have a Grandfather. Well maybe we didn't, but there was still an old man with an accent. And my mother was there the night they took me away. And I think my brother and I both know who was with her. **************************** I burned with bright indignation on the way up to Connecticut. Driving home now, I am just ashamed of myself. The last time I confronted her and demanded answers to my questions, she slapped my face hard and stormed up the stairs. Not this time. Why was I asking her these questions? What did I want her to tell me? The truth I said. Just tell the truth. She started to cry. Whatever happened it was my father's fault. It was him. She couldn't remember. In the end, I packed her off to bed with a cup of soup and her Brahms tape. Now I drive along wishing I'd never gone in the first place. I can save the image of her frightened face right next to the look on Sam's face when Werber woke her up. The path on my road to truth is littered with so many broken hearts and bodies. What a fuck I am. **************************** When the call comes I am strangely not surprised. Scully and I are on our way to lunch. I have to pull the car over. "Mulder, what is it? What's happened?" I see the fear in her face and it distresses me. Don't be afraid Scully. "Can you drop me at home? I was supposed to meet Sam after her Oral." She looks at me like I'm out of mind. Of course, I am. ******************************* The old elevator gently knocks back and forth climbing toward my brother's floor, I am happy and ready to celebrate. The exam went exceptionally well, but then, you began preparing me ten years ago. I knock on his door, trying to be patient. Finally he opens the door. Oh fuck. "Scully?" I say. His eyes are red-rimmed and bloodshot. His hair is standing up a little on one side, as if he's been dragging fingers through it. "Mom," he says quietly, putting his gun back in the shoulder holster, picking up his jacket from the chair in front of the desk. "Another stroke?" I follow him, trying to get in front of him. I want to see his face. "No. She's dead," he looks at me for an instant, but then he moves his eyes to the empty fish tank. "She killed herself." I follow his gaze to the tank, gulping at the air like the fish. "What? When?" everything is happening in slow motion, except that I can't think fast enough to keep up. "She killed herself. Swallowed a fucking bottle of sleeping pills with half a bottle of vodka. Because I..." his voice cracks and his face scrunches up. His head tilts back, his arms hang long, dangling at his sides, and he sobs, "Because I grilled her, interrogated her the way I questions serial killers," his voice is disgusted, dripping with self-hatred. We ride in silence through Maryland and New Jersey. In New York I tell him it wasn't his fault. His reaction is swift and violent. He slams the steering wheel hard. Very hard. "What do you know?" he yells, slamming the wheel some more. The car swerves into the next lane. As he moves to correct, he over-corrects because we're going 80 mph. We swerve back across the two right lanes. "Pull over Fox. Stop the car. Now!" I thunder at him. Amazingly, he does pull the car off to the shoulder. For a few minutes, neither of us speak. The only sound comes from the other cars streaking past us rocking our car gently with the air's displacement. "She was a little old lady, confused and frightened, and I needled, accused, circled..." he is saying it slowly. His arms cross over the steering wheel and he brings his head down to lean on them. I see his shoulders shake and I know he is crying. I feel my nose itch and tears well in my eyes. I don't cry for my mother, I cry for my brother. I lean toward him, putting my hand on his back, lightly stroking. In a moment he turns his head to look at me. When he sees the tears on my face, he misunderstands and sits up, pulling me close. "Oh Sam, I'm so sorry. You never got the chance to work it out with her." I think to myself in a strangely detached way that we Mulder children have a very serious problem with guilt. I doubt that I would ever have worked it out with my mother. He'll never understand why I have to keep hating her, even dead. But because of my memory he confronted her, and now she is dead and he thinks it was his fault. I feel awful. **************************** Arriving in Greenwich, CT, I marvel at my brother. The house is still swarming with police and he moves about them in a practiced grace. He commands respect not just because he is the victim's son, but because he is an FBI agent, the cream of the crop. He moves around the house, looking at everything. And then he does it again and again. I can see the wheels in his mind working as he pieces together the events that led to this tragedy. It seems neither the time or place, but I feel ridiculously proud of him. I want to take all the cops aside and be sure they know he's my brother. This is why I never forgot him in all those years. He is brilliant, he is special. He catches killers. He solves the unsolvable crimes. I move around the house by myself now and pause, finally, in what would have been my room. It's next to Fox's room. Some of the furniture I recognize from my room long, long ago. I sit down in the old rocking chair. Did she ever rock us as babies in this chair? Perhaps. Have I been wrong about my mother? I hadn't wanted to come up here last week. In fact I'd been dreading it since that first day. I didn't have the courage to talk to Fox about it. The psychologist in him would have understood, but not the brother, I think. I have come to terms with the fact that the mother I killed in the convenience store was a substitute for the mother I wanted to kill. I have a very strict idea of what a mother's job is. She is to protect her children from all harm, raising them in a safe and secure environment. My mother failed miserably at that. In not standing up to my father when he abused Fox, she left the job to me, a six year old child. I don't have a good picture of what happened after I was taken, but I can't believe things got better for him. But because I thought I owed him, and because I thought I was emotionally detached enough, had analyzed these feelings of hatred enough, and had in fact already killed a mother to satisfy my blood lust, I agreed to meet with my mother again. It was a disaster from the first moment. The house smelled just like our old house in Chilmark. I was on edge immediately, the haze lifting from the memories, bringing clarity to things that would have been better left blurry. She approached me slowly. She put her hand to my hair, fingertips just barely touching the gray streak over my right ear. It scared me a little. I didn't know why at the time, though I do now. I looked to my brother for reassurance and the look on his face broke my heart. The look was unmistakable. The love she showed my brother had always been conditional. Here he was, thirty six years old, having spent the last twenty four years working toward bringing me home to fulfill the condition. He just wanted her to love him, but I could see, this wasn't the condition. The day went downhill from there. She became even more aloof. Any attempt my brother made to discuss what had happen was dismissed. As I think back on that moment now, I realize something. She was afraid of me. She was afraid I would remember her being there when I was taken. Not just the night they came for me, but later, in the bloody diaper days. She'd touched my hair the same way, but it was falling out then. It makes her motive for suicide more plausible. She didn't tell my brother anything, but how long could she stall him? How long did she have before we found the truth? In trying to understand the motive for her silence and her fear of discovery, I am forced to wonder just who she was protecting. "Here you are," Fox says coming in to sit on the bed. "Are you ok?" He is a well-trained observer isn't he. I nod at him, because I don't want to get into it just yet. "Scully's here. She's going to do the autopsy." "You don't think it was suicide?" "I don't know. It might have been assisted." I frown at this. "The neighbor across the street says I was the only person he saw leaving last night, but the time doesn't jive. I left by seven, he thought it was ten. He is quite elderly," he concludes, but absently. Then, with greater animation he pulls his hand out of his pocket. "I found these." I stare at the miniature electronic listening devices. "Bugs?" I ask, he nods affirmatively. "How would you know where to look? Why would you look?" "The lamp in the living room. I was looking for something else. When I found one, I kept looking." "What were you looking for in the lamp?" "An ice pick." "What?" "It's a long story. I think we should get some sleep. We can talk more in the morning." **************************** I lie here waiting to sleep. I am exhausted, but there is so much going through my mind. Of course, sleeping in this room that might have been mine is a little weird. I can hear the muffled sounds of my brother and Scully talking in the living room. I tried not to stare at her, but I caught myself looking for some trace, some sign of her cancer. Fox says she gets nose bleeds, that the frequency has increased significantly in the last few weeks. I could see the fear in his eyes as he told me. I remember seeing something like it in your eyes. You held my hand in the ambulance as they transferred me from the prison. You were just as stubborn as he seems to be. You guys just don't take death sentences well, do you? An ice pick? **************************** I know the minute I step into my house that someone has been here or is still here. I set my bag down on the floor and slip out of my shoes. Creeping silently across the hall into the living room, nothing seems out of place, but there is a small package on the kitchen table. A gift wrapped package, like a large jewelry box. A graduation present. I open the broom closest. Nothing. Upstairs, nothing. I sit down in front of the package. A gold cloth bow wrapped around a gold box. There is no store name on it, no card. I rattle it. Something shifts slightly from side to side. I take a deep breath and pull the bow open. Inside I find a piece of paper with an address and a number on it. The piece of paper is wrapped around a key. I recognize the kind of key, and my heart pounds hard in my chest. It's a safe deposit key. This one to a bank I've never been to before. I close my eyes, fighting back tears. I'm not sure if I'm happy or sad. **************************** I am remembering the end of May, 1993. You didn't call, didn't come by. I followed your procedure and waited another week, not eating or sleeping. Just watching, listening. Trying not to chew my nails past the quick. And then, still following your instructions, I took the key to the bank and found my name and signature on their safe deposit records, though I had never set foot in the bank before. The young teller showed me into a tiny room with that large box. There were several envelopes, marked in the order you wanted me to read them. I stepped out of the room an hour later, shell- shocked. I don't remember getting home. What will I find in this box? Is it from you? Who is pulling these strings now? Who put my diary on Fox's doorstep? Who bugged Mom's house? It seems so hard. I want to curl up some place and sleep. I'm afraid of what I'll find. I'm afraid to do this anymore without you. Without someone. I want to trust my brother. I need to trust him. **************************** We're sitting in his living room, ostensibly planning her funeral. He's looking for a Wordsworth poem Mom used to liked. I steal glimpses of him, trying to decide. I have two equally convincing scenarios mapped out. Two equally fantastic, yet still plausible explanations. What am I waiting for? "Fox..." I begin, but the phone cuts me off. "Mulder," he continues after a minute, "No, you have the wrong number....Yes, I'm sure it's not... who is this?" his brows are knitted. He hits three keys on the phone, the call back feature. I ask him what the call was about. A recording tells him the number is not in his service area. "Gemini Biological Labs," he says, as if that should be a sufficient explanation. He's pulls Metro, Suburban Maryland, and Virginia phone books off the shelf onto the desk and he's pawing through the G-section. "Millbrook." "Just a second, Sam." "Millbrook, New York." "What?" he turns around. "Gemini Biological is in Millbrook. New York State." I tell him as I slip the photos out of the envelope I found in the safe deposit box. Our eyes hold for a brief, very awkward moment. "Where did you get these?" "Just look at them," I ask. I watch his face intently as he reviews them. He looks, closely, at every detail of each of the three photos. Then he crosses back to the desk, sits down, removes a magnifying glass from the top drawer and goes over them again. I lean against the window sill, watching him, waiting. "As far as I can tell, these are genuine. But I have no memory of this meeting, nor do I recall the name Gemini Biological Supply. I can take them to the lab for analysis... where did you get these Sam?" I turn around and rest my arms against the cross bar of the window pane, watching the street below. "There was a package on my kitchen table when you dropped me off. All wrapped up like a graduation present. A key inside, a safe deposit key. Just like the ones he left me when he died." My nose is itching again. There is just no way this is going to end happily-ever-after I think to myself as I blink back the tears I can't afford. "What do you think this is about?" he asks me, his voice sounding as tired as mine. "Hybrids, clones, one or both," I say. "You think..." "Yeah, I do." I understand, probably better than most, that it's a sobering proposition. "Think we should take a drive up there?" "I think I should." "We, Fox. We. I'm in this," I insist, motioning to the photos still before him on the desk. "It might be dangerous." "I can handle it," I say and he actually snorts! I pull one last item from the envelope, a photo ID, and throw it on the desk. He looks at me murderously. **************************** Heading north on 95, just past the beltway, he says: "Time to explain," he is curt, angry. The vein is still standing up on his forehead. I think he probably still gets monster headaches. "It's not that I deceived you," I begin, "I haven't. I simply wasn't in a position to trust you before." He whips around and gives me the dirtiest of looks. "Come on, you know the message he gave Scully. Trust no one. It wasn't a hard lesson for me to learn. But he taught it like a parent teaches bed-time prayers. Say it every night before you go to sleep. Believe it, live it." I pause, "I had to be sure about you." Now he is indignant, bordering on furious. "Hey, forgive me ok? We're talking about trust here and I can't think of one lesson we learned growing up that would inspire us to trust, can you? I didn't think so." I don't even wait for him to reply, I don't need to. "He came after me in prison because he thought I might be useful. That was the reason, initially. But he did a little digging, and he developed some different ideas. The way this has happened, how he orchestrated it, even from beyond the grave, it's amazing, brilliant. He was a master strategist. The greatest chess player." I think that I will always pale beside my memory of you. I'll never be as good as it takes. As good as you were. I want to know the truth, but I am afraid of the consequences. "What is this? Le Femme Nikkita?" he is still very angry and it takes only a nanosecond for my self pity to turn white hot. "Le Femme Nikkita? Is that what you think? That he turned me into a god-damned assassin? Thanks a lot. Give me a little credit, will you? No, Fox, I'm not some blow Ôem and blow Ôem away bitch. I'm a planner, like him. Ask me what happens if an IRA bomb explodes in Heathrow Airport on Sunday morning or on a Tuesday evening. Ask me what happens in Moscow if that happens, or Tel Aviv or in Silverplume, Colorado. I can tell you, and I can tell you why it makes a bigger difference in Silverplume if it happens on a Tuesday evening. "And the rice crops in North Korea. Do you have any idea what's about to happen. I'll tell you this much, it's not what you think. "Le Femme Nikkita. Jesus Christ. It was a hell of a lot closer to My Fair Lady if you must know." Arrogant SOB, literally! Asshole. Butt-Munch! All of these words sail through my head and then I realize he's beginning to laugh. It starts small, but it's building to a real belly shaker. "What is so funny?" I ask him, finding it difficult to keep the edge of irritation in my voice. "Just you wait Henry Higgins, just you wait!" he's singing to me. I shake my head. Fine. I start singing along with him. If you can't beat them... **************************** It's dark when we arrive at Gemini Biological Supply. We pull up to the guard station, ready to show our IDs, but the guard waves us through after a cursory glance. He does it with a smile and a nod. We park in front of the three story glass building pictured in the photos I shared with my brother. As we do, we hear a car door close behind us. I smell it almost right away. What a keen nose I have. We turn toward the noise and a cigarette glows in the night. I wonder absently where the camera is now. "Agent Mulder. Ms. Fox," he says stepping past us, and holding the door for us. I can tell that my brother is just barely containing his anger. For my part, I swallow hard at the bile that rises in my throat thinking about our last encounter. I squeeze my eyes tight for a moment, blocking out the vision of the sweat gathered on his twitching upper lip as he becomes aroused, ÔTell me again about your childhood...about your brother.' His breathing ragged. He's a pain junkie. I can't stop the shiver on this warm August evening. "Won't you follow me?" he says as we step past the security desk to the elevators. We ride to the third floor in silence. He lights another cigarette and smiles. Fox and I only make eye contact a few times. He is seething. The elevator doors open onto a plush executive level. The receptionist's desk is vacant now, but the door going to the big office is ajar. Our cigarette smoking guide pushes it open, allowing us to pass before him. The executive chair swivels around and I hear my brother gasp. "You don't fucking let up do you? She's dead, because of you. Because of you and your pathetic search for the truth." He stands and moves around the desk, coming to stop in front my brother. This is the man that my mother has been protecting all this time. At my brother's expense, at my expense. It starts to happen so fast... This is the man that ordered your death, I realize. "Well here's your truth, you asshole," he says, pointing to his own face. My brother's eyes run over him, head to foot. He searches the other's face. I know he looking for some trace of alien DNA. Perhaps he thinks he's found it, in the eyes. I notice something in the eyes. "A hybrid," my brother says, finally able to speak. The man laughs heartily and then just as quickly, he sneers, and shakes his head from side to side, and then looks at me. "You know, don't you?" My brother follows his gaze to me. I have to nod my head. My brother looks confused. When he returns his attention to the figure standing before him, he repeats, "You're a hybrid," his hands open in a gesture of reasonableness. "No, I am Fox William Mulder. You are the hybrid, Agent Mulder," he insists, reaching for my brother's hand as if he could prove it, but my brother yanks it away, clutching both hands close to his body as he takes a step back, away from him. "No. I refuse to accept... my blood... Scully's never found..." he stammers. I can almost see the images that must be flooding his mind. "Of course not!" The original Fox cuts him off. He leans against the desk. I hear a lighter click. "She'd only find it if she knew where to look for it. You're the first, an early generation. An inferior generation. There have been two more since." he says with growing pride. Dread creeps up my spine. "You're too human, not enough alien. You're weak...you can't breathe under water," he says, and it's spoken like an accusation, "although you are a better swimmer than I am. But that's the only thing I can say for you. "How do you think you survived that retro-virus? It wasn't just your partner's medical skill. And the black cancer? You may be immune to that too. But other than that, a complete failure. You don't have the increased strength or stamina or the heightened sensory perceptions, your brain power is good, but not as good as mine." "But, I don't understand," there is an edge in his voice. He reels around to look at me, his look pleading with me. If this is true, his eyes tell me, then everything he knows, everything he believes, is a lie. "You were living a wonderfully fulfilling and nurtured life here in the lab." Fox's voice draws my brother back, "We played together. Did you know that? Klemper liked observing us, so Mother used to bring me over to play with you, and I didn't mind. I was your teacher. My life became your life. My memories, your memories. We still use similar patterning today. Drugging the subjects makes them susceptible to suggestion. The suggestion becomes memory. Memory becomes history. Bear this is mind, my inferior second, if we can wipe a memory, why couldn't we create one?" he starts to laugh at this. Something strikes him as just hilarious, and then he is suddenly serious again. "I have to give you this. You have always been, at the very least, amusing. I have really enjoyed watching you work over the years. Some of the leaps you've made... I used to worry you'd get yourself killed. Strange, isn't it? I suppose I thought of you like some sort of brother, or maybe even a son." As I look at my brother I see he has heard little of this. He's pale and shocky. Finally he says, in a voice that sounds far away, "When?" It takes us all a moment to realize what he's asking. How much of his life was spent in the laboratory, how much of his past is manufactured? "Things were coming along fine until my father started having some problems with his conscience," Fox tells him. "Of course, they already knew you weren't the end result they were looking for, but you were just what they needed to keep him in line. An everyday reminder for dear old Dad. Tow the project line, maybe get your real son back. "Do you remember when they brought him, Samantha?" I step forward, closer to my brother. Scully calls him Mulder. I'm training myself to call him Mulder. "I thought he was our Grandfather," I say to him, Mulder, "but it must have been Klemper." It seems to relieve him just a bit, but it's breaking my heart to see him like this, to have him find out like this. I had to consider this as a possibility after I received the pictures. It was really the only conclusion that I could draw based on all the facts. If I had thought I could tell him and have him believe me... I understand the difference in their eyes. My brother's eyes reflect compassion and a great depth of character. Fox's eyes... Fox's eyes are an illustration of madness. "You know, of course that he hated you," Fox taunts my brother, "He never beat me. Never beat Samantha..." I see my brother's hands clenching and realize my own are doing the same thing. I hear your voice telling me not to be rash. Weight the situation. Evaluate your options. Follow the scenarios. Pick the best path. I say them over and over again to myself, like mantra. I don't know what possesses me to look behind me, but I do. He's puffing away on the cancer stick with the outline of an erection in his pants. I knew it would be there. The hate wells up in me. They are not worthy of life. They took your life. They are out to destroy what is left of my life and my brother's. I move to stand in front of my brother. I reach for his hand pulling the fist into my palm and stroking it, never taking my eyes from his. Finally his eyes shift from Fox's to mine and his hand relaxes. "You are my brother," I whisper to him, "You are my brother." "Oh Samantha, for God's sake!" Fox says to me, his hand now on my shoulder, pulling me around to face him. "He's a copy. A faulty copy. But you should see what we're doing now. Come look," he motions to the glass behind his desk excitedly. We can see that it looks out on some factory floor. But somehow we missed the tanks until now. At least I did. We don't move to join him at the glass though. He addresses my brother again and his demeanor has changed from convivial to inimical, "As soon as you brought Samantha home to Mother you be came a liability. You actually interrogated her! My Mother, not yours! You were not born of her womb. You were conceived in a fucking petri dish, gestated in a 25 gallon fish tank, a combination of my cells and some alien DNA for parents. You never traveled down any birth canal, nor nursed at a mother's breast. You are the reason she's dead, you freak," he roars. "No," I yell at him, "You are. You are the reason she's dead. She sacrificed herself for you. You showed up at her house after my brother left. You heard what went on and you went down to silence her. What did you say to her last night to make her drink half a bottle of vodka with a handful of sleeping pills? Did you shame her into it? Did you stand over her, drink this, eat another?" I step behind the desk, leaning close to him as I continue my assault. "She didn't act on his words, she acted on your words, didn't she? You take the blame for this and you take the blame for Dad. He was going to tell Mulder everything, wasn't he? "The program may have been amoral to begin with, but now it's a perversion of that twisted morality, light years from the original goal. He was going to tell Mulder that the man running the program was mad, a crazed Dr. Frankenstein. He was going to tell Mulder the truth, that his son was a madman. "Well I've got news for you Doctor, just like the story, your monsters are rebelling and they're coming for your head..." the vein in his forehead is standing up a good quarter of an inch or more and he tries to grab me around the throat. He's got the strength of a madman alright, but I'm sliding in his grip, separating his hands, spinning him around so I can stand behind him and drop him to the floor. I see my brother moving toward me. I push Fox towards the floor, arm twisted behind him. The Cigarette Man pulls his gun and aims for me, but he never gets a chance to fire. My brother has seen him. In less than the blink of an eye, I have brought Fox to his knees, face in the carpet, and my brother's gun has the Cancerman sliding down the wall leaving a bright red streak of blood. A minute? Five minutes? pass without a word between us. Finally, my brother replaces his gun in the holster and pulls a cell phone from his pocket. The first call is to Scully. **************************** The three of us are sitting on a too-soft double bed at a motel in Clinton Corners, just off the Taconic Parkway. Fox has been sedated and lies hog-tied on the bed in the adjoining room. We have finally agreed that we will hide him in an institution under an assumed name until things at Gemini can be sorted out. Scully goes to lie down, but not before laying a gentle hand on my brother's shoulder. She doesn't need to say anything, he knows. "Hey Scully, leave the door open. I'm paranoid about leaving you alone with my look-alikes," he tells her holding her hand to his shoulder for a brief moment. She rolls her eyes but obliges him. After she's left and I hear water running in the bathroom next door, I take his hand in mine and scoot closer to him so I can whisper, "There is a way to save her, I think." He cocks his head to the side, his brows drawn together. He looks completely wiped out. Who wouldn't be? I am too. "The rebelling hybrids," I say. "Remember, you told me about the hybrids you found at the Research Facility where they were storing Scully's eggs? You said they were trying to sabotage the project." He's nodding. "I think they would know what to do with this." I hand him a tape. A DAT tape. He looks like he's going to freak on me. "What is this?" it comes out as a harsh, between his normal voice and a whisper. "Medical records..." He's shaking his head, he doesn't follow again. "And notes from Dr. Berube on the procedure." His eyebrows shoot up at mention of this name. "The hybrids would have access to what you need to save her life," I continue, "What did you tell me you were working on when Deep Throat was killed? Purity Control, right?" I see his eyes lighten. He's got it. "The subject, Dr. Secare, he had cancer. They all had cancer! But wait, he's the only one that survived..." I'm shaking my head no. He looks at the DAT tape in his hand and then back at me. The clouds are back in his eyes. "I told you he saved my life. He didn't just educate me and provide for me financially. We didn't discover I had AIDs until late 1992, and by then it was full blown. Prison health care is inconsistent. Anyway, it's not surprising, given my previous lifestyle. "It took him another few months to arrange his Ôtreatment'. But when he came for me, I thought he was taking me someplace to die. I had had a series of infections, all were treated, but not without some profound weight loss. And then they diagnosed PCP, AIDs pneumonia. Having lost most of my left lung to a different pneumonia seven years earlier, there was no way I was going to survive. "I don't remember much of the treatment. I was pretty out of it at first. There was pain. A piece of you has to die in order to be reborn. A few months later there was no sign of AIDs, HIV or any of the secondary infections." "I don't know what to say. There's so much I don't understand," he says. "We'll have the time one of these days. In the meantime, we could both use some sleep. I know I'll have my hands full tomorrow." "You're sure you can manage him?" Now it's my turn to roll my eyes at him. "I just told you - I have superior strength, can breath under water and I could probably photosynthesize if I ate a better diet. I can handle him." "I can't do any of those things," he says, sadly. "No, but every day you go out and make the world a better place to live," I pull him in for a hug, "It feels so good to have you back." "You too, Sam. You too." **************************** I lie awake listening to the people sleeping around me. Sam is silent. Scully occasionally snorts softly from the room adjoining ours. He.... God, I don't even know what to call him, what to call myself. He doesn't snore, probably because of the drugs. A first generation hybrid. Something less alien and more human. Something to remind the man I thought of as my father that he'd made a deal with the devil. That night in Quonochontaug. No wonder Mother was screaming about her babies. No wonder she didn't want that black-lunged monster taking Sam, leaving her alone with it, with me. The freak. I roll over, pulling my knees into my chest. Holding it all in hurts. The look in his eye as my arm twisted away from my body. Hate. The look on her face when I'd call her. Happiness for split second, replaced by sadness. She could never love me. The mattress shifts and I feel Sam's body next to mine, pulling me into her embrace. "You are my brother," she whispers, my eyes burn. **************************** I checked Fox into the sanatorium without incident. I don't think they'll be able to find him. I feel sorry for him. How can I not? He mocked my brother for having gestated in a fish tank, but in the end, he found a life outside the lab. Fox never did. I think about my brother now and hope that he will eventually find peace with himself. He has a tough decision to make, but in making it, he will define himself. I had to give him a way to save Scully. I owed him that. Whether he chooses to use it or not... If he does, he risks becoming what they were, what you were. And if he doesn't, and Scully dies... I hope he'll appreciate the strength of what he believes in, and allow that to ease his guilt. I have emailed him the poem you gave me the day I completed my conversion. I hope he'll find some truth in it. I love Russia, but I miss you terribly. I had a silly dream that I would be with you when I saw it for the first time. I am excited to begin this new job and I will endeavor to make you proud of me. This tea room is something else. It looks as if it started out as stark and austere as the Soviet Union, and in those heady first days after the fall of communism, somebody over-dressed it in cheap velvet curtains and flocked wallpaper. But like Russia today, the wall paper is peeling and the curtains are frayed, bits of the Soviet Union are showing themselves again. The bells by the door chime as a man enters. I think he must be the one I'm waiting for, your golden boy. He strips off his sunglasses like a model and moves toward my table. He sets a prosthetic hand on the back of the chair. "I'm Alex," he says. "Call me Kathy," I tell him. **************************** They say that Hope is happiness; But genuine Love must prize the past, And Memory wakes the thoughts that bless: They rose the first Ñthey set the last; And all that Memory loves the most Was once our only Hope to be, And all that Hope adored and lost Hath melted into Memory. Alas! it is delusion all; The future cheats us from afar, Nor can we be what we recall, Nor dare we think on what we are. ÑGeorge Gordon, Lord Byron, 1816 End... of this episode anyway. ]